Marital rape-Rape and Marriage

Introduction

Requirements in a relationship: A relationship between two individuals, including marriage, is built around love, respect, trust and consent.
Within that civilised framework, a violent and exploitative act like rape has no place.

Recent SC stance on rape and marriage

Seen in that context, the Supreme Court’s latest query to a Maharashtra government employee asking whether he would marry a girl he was accused of raping repeatedly while she was a minor is insensitive to the core.
By offering marriage as a solution to a rape victim, the judiciary failed to protect the rights of a girl.
Instead of meting out harsh punishment, the Court asked the lawyer representing the accused to find out whether his client would be willing to marry the victim or risk going to jail.

This can lead to an act of misogyny

Equal rights activists have always worked hard against misogyny, patriarchal mindsets and other failings such as blaming the victim for the rape.
This arduous battle for equality becomes even more difficult when people in high offices make offensive remarks.

Supreme court on marital rape

In another case, the Bench stayed the arrest of a man accused of rape after falsely promising marriage. The victim said she was promised marriage and was “brutally and sexually abused”.
- The CJI asked the girl’s lawyer: “When two people are living as husband and wife, however brutal the husband is, can you call sexual intercourse between them ‘rape’?”
- In both cases, these crimes attract severe penalties under the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013.

Justice J.S. Verma Committee on marital rape

- On marital rape, though the recommendation was not included in the Act, the Justice J.S. Verma Committee was clear the law ought to specify that a marital or another relationship between the perpetrator and victim cannot be a defence against sexual violation.

C.R. vs U.K case

- Citing the judgment of the European Commission of Human Rights in C.R. vs the U.K., it endorsed the conclusion that “a rapist remains a rapist regardless of his relationship with the victim”.

Shimbhu & Anr vs State of Haryana (2013)

- In Shimbhu & Anr vs State of Haryana (2013), the Supreme Court said the offer of a rapist to marry the victim cannot be used to reduce the sentence prescribed by law.

Conclusion

- The law should deliver justice, not blatantly tilt the scales against women’s rights.

Source: TH

Join Our Telegram

Sedition in India

Economic revival from the economic recession

Public Interest Litigation

07 May, 26
SHARE

The increasing scrutiny of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in India highlights a growing tension between its role as a tool for constitutional justice and its emerging misuse for non-public or extraneous purposes. While PIL has significantly expanded access to justice under Article 21, concerns have emerged regarding its distortion, judicial o

Supreme Court on Hate Speech

07 May, 26
SHARE

The Supreme Court of India recently observed that hate speech, driven by an “us versus them” mindset, poses a serious threat to the constitutional values of fraternity, equality, and social harmony. The Court emphasized that the major issue is not the absence of laws but the poor implementation of existing legal provisions. Therefor

India’s Fiscal Outlook

08 May, 26
SHARE

The Ministry of Finance, in its recent Monthly Economic Review, has expressed concern over the fiscal health of several Indian states. The report warns that states with high revenue deficits, rising debt burdens, and heavy interest payment obligations may struggle to cope with future fiscal shocks or economic slowdowns. Fiscal Position of th

Abortion Law for Minor Rape Survivors

08 May, 26
SHARE

Recent Judicial Development The Supreme Court has urged the Union government to consider amending India’s abortion law to remove rigid time limits in cases involving minor rape victims. This observation came while the Court declined to entertain a curative petition filed by the government challenging a recent judgment that allowed a 15

NSO Survey on Health

05 May, 26
SHARE

The National Statistical Office (NSO) 80th Round Survey on Household Consumption on Health provides a detailed assessment of India’s healthcare access, morbidity patterns, and financial burden of health expenditure. The findings highlight a paradoxical situation where healthcare access has improved significantly, but financial vulnerabili