Editorial Plus

GS-II : International Relations

Cartographic challenge: On Pakistan’s new map

07 August, 2020
10 Min Read

Cartographic challenge: On Pakistan’s new map

Context

The Ministry of External Affairs has termed Pakistan’s announcement of a new political map, which asserts its claims on Jammu and Kashmir, Siachen and Sir Creek, and lays a new claim to Junagadh, as an exercise in “political absurdity”, and accused Pakistan of attempting a form of “territorial aggrandisement supported by cross-border terrorism”.

Pakistan’s new map

Pakistan’s decision to issue the map, a tit-for-tat manoeuvre in return for India’s decision to reorganise Jammu and Kashmir a year ago, appears to reset several agreements with India that have been concretised over the past 70 years.
The map the Imran Khan government unveiled lays claim to all of Jammu and Kashmir, thus far shown as disputed territory, draws a line demarcating Gilgit-Baltistan separately from the part of Kashmir under its control (Pakistan occupied Kashmir), and renames Jammu and Kashmir as “Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir”.
The new map leaves the claim line with Ladakh unclear.
While each of these acts is outrageous for New Delhi, it should also be questioned in Islamabad. Pakistan’s claim to all of Jammu and Kashmir, but not Ladakh, goes against its own commitment to adjudicate the future of all six parts of the erstwhile royal state of Jammu-Kashmir (Jammu, Kashmir, Ladakh, Gilgit-Baltistan, PoK and Aksai Chin) with India.
The claims to Siachen and Sir Creek, that have been the subject of several discussions between India and Pakistan, are also a regressive step.
While both sides had reached an impasse on Siachen, the Sir Creek agreement had made considerable progress, and was reportedly even resolved, pending a political announcement in 2007.
Finally, the move on Junagadh, a former princely state whose accession to India was accepted by Pakistan, opens up a whole new dispute.
While Junagadh was in contention at the time of Partition, the issue was successfully resolved after a referendum was conducted there in February 1948, in which an overwhelming 95% of the state’s residents voted to stay with India.

Way forward

Pakistan’s actions, while on completely bilateral matters, come in conjunction with map-related issues India faces today on two other fronts: with China at the Line of Actual Control on Ladakh, and with Nepal at Kalapani and Limpiyadhura.
It is surely no coincidence that all three countries objected to the map New Delhi had issued in November 2019, albeit for different reasons, and New Delhi must be well-prepared to deal with the three-pronged cartographic challenge it will face in the coming months.

Source: TH

Join Our Telegram

Can the NEP aid access to universal education?

Important Editorials

Organisation Of Turkic State and India-Turkey Relation

Tribal Welfare

Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI): Deep Analysis

Indo Pacific Region: Detailed Overview

IMPORTANT CHINESE PRESIDENTS AND THEIR CONTRIBUTION

Creating safe digital spaces

India’s position in Afghanistan

MPLAD SCHEME

Will India be sanctioned for the S-400 purchase?

Retail Direct Scheme and The Integrated Ombudsman

Was it really a black hole that the EHT imaged in 2019

From revolution to oligarchy in Nicaragua

NVBDCP National Vector Borne Disease Control Programme

CLIMATE CHANGE AND COP 26

Non-Aligned Movement: Detailed Overview

The lowdown on India’s Glasgow announcement

Afghanistan - Issue and Crisis, Detailed Analysis

Does India have a right to burn fossil fuels?

India Pakistan Fishermen Issue

Breaking down the hype around Metaverse

It’s time to engage in ‘lawfare’

Schemes to deal with Malnutrition in India

Energy Sector Reforms

Delay in MGNREGA Payment

AUKUS could rock China’s boat in the Indo-Pacific

Ethiopian Tigray Crisis

Where does India stand on methane emissions?

India Afghanistan Relations

RESERVATION IN INDIA

The right time for India to have its own climate law

Quick Links Testimonials FAQ

Crash Course

Regular Modules 2022

Mains

Optional

Cartographic challenge: On Pakistan’s new map

Important Editorials

Top Editorials

Toppers

Search By Date

UPSC Courses

Sanjeevani Prelims Crash Course 2021

Saarthi Mentorship Programme

Foundation Batches

Module wise Prelims Batches

Mains Batches

Test Series

Post Feed

Important Tags

Articles:Geography And Environment

Articles: History Culture Society

Articles: Governance & National Issues

Articles: IR & IO

Articles: Economic Development & Economic Issues

Articles: S&T Internal Security

Articles: Ethics & Others

Articles: Others

Newsletter Subscription

SMS Alerts