×

UPSC Courses

DNA banner

DAILY NEWS ANALYSIS

  • 20 June, 2021

  • 15 Min Read

National Human Rights Commission and State Human Rights Commission, 1993

National Human Rights Commission and State Human Rights Commission, 1993

What is the news?

  • The Calcutta High Court has directed the Chairperson of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) to constitute a committee to examine complaints of post-poll violence in West Bengal.
  • A Bench of five judges directed that the committee “shall examine all the cases, and maybe by visiting the affected areas, and submit a comprehensive report to this court about the present situation”.
  • The court asked the committee to suggest “steps to be taken to ensure confidence of the people that they can peacefully live in their houses and also carry on their occupation or business to earn their livelihood”. The order, issued on June 18, directed that “the persons prima facie responsible for crime and the officers who maintained calculated silence on the issue be pointed out”.

NHRC and SHRC, 1993

  • Both are Statutory Autonomous bodies established under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
  • It is the watchdog of Human Rights in India. They are Rights w.r.t. Life, Liberty, Equality & dignity guaranteed by the Constitution or of International Covenants. Accordingly 25 States have constituted SHRCs through official Gazette Notifications.

NHRC

SHRC

  1. Composition of NHRC: Chairman, 4 members and 4 Ex-officio members.
  2. Qualifications for NHRC:
    1. The chairperson should be a Retd. CJI and
    2. Members should be Serving or Retired Judge of SC, a Serving or Retd CJHC and 2 persons having practical experience of Human Rights.
    3. 4 Ex-officio members are Chairmen Of the National Commission of Minorities, SCs, STs, and Women.
  3. Appointment: by Prez on the recommendations of a 6-member Committee: PM as its head, Speaker of Lok Sabha, Deputy Chairman of Rajya Sabha, Leader of Opposition in both Houses of Parliament and Home Minister.
  4. Further, a sitting Judge of SC or a sitting Chief Justice of HC can be appointed only after consultation of CJI.
  1. Composition of SHRC: Chairperson & 2 members.
  2. Qualifications for SHRC:
    1. Chairperson should be a Retd. CJHC and
    2. Members should be serving or Retd. Judge of HC or Dist Judge in the State for > 7 years’ experience and having knowledge or practical experience of human rights.
  3. Appointment by Gov (but removal by Prez) on the recommendation of a Committee consisting of CM as its head, Speaker of Legislative Assembly, State Home Minister and Leader of Opposition of Legislative Assembly. If State has LC, then the committee also has Chairman of LC and Leader of Opposition of LC. Further, a sitting JoHC or a sitting Dist Judge can be appointed only after consultation of CJHC of the State concerned.

  • Tenure (of both NHRC & SHRC): 3 years or 70 years whichever is earlier. Not eligible for further Employment under Center or States.
  • Removal (of both NHRC & SHRC) by Prez: (Same as of UPSC, CVC, CIC) Removal is done only by Prez under the following conditions:
    1. If he has gone bankrupt or If, according to Prez, he is of unsound mind or If he is involved in paid employment outside the duties of office.
    2. Prez can also remove her in case of Misbehavior or incapacity (defined in Constitution), Prez refers this matter to SC. SC’s decision is binding on Prez. Then he may remove it. During the course of an enquiry by the SC, Prez can suspend them.
  • The salary, allowances & service conditions are determined by C / S govt & can’t be varied to his disadvantage post appointment.
  • Functions of Both:
    1. To strengthen the institutional arrangements through which human rights could be addressed in their entirety and in a more focused manner.
    2. To inquire into any violation of Human Rights, either suo motu or on a petition presented to it or an order of a Court. SHRC can only enquire into matters related w State List or Concurrent List of the 7th Schedule of the Constitution. However, if any such case is enquired by NHRC or any other Statutory Commission, then SHRC doesn’t inquire into that case.
    3. To intervene in any proceeding involving allegation of violation of Human rights pending before a Court.
    4. To visit jails or detention places, study the living conditions of inmates and make recommendations.
    5. To review the Constitution and legal safeguards for the protection of HRs and make recommendations.
    6. To review the factors including acts of terrorism that inhibit the enjoyment of rights and recommend remedial measures.
    7. To spread human rights literacy and encourage the efforts of NGOs working in this direction.
    8. To study treaties and international agreements on Human Rights and make recommendations.
    9. To undertake and promote research in the field of Human Rights.
    10. To undertake such other functions as it may consider necessary for the promotion of human rights.
  • Working:
    1. It can't by itself punish the guilty. That is the responsibility of courts. It makes independent and credible enquiry into any case of violation of human rights. Also if any govt officer neglects.
    2. It regulates its own procedure. It has all the powers of a Civil Court and its proceedings have a judicial character. It may call for info or reporty from C & S govts or any subordinate authority.
    3. The NHRC has its own nucleus of working staff for investigation. Besides, it is empowered to utilize the services of any officer or investigating agency of C or S govt. It has also established effective coop with NGOs with 1st hand info about HR violations.
    4. It can only look into the matter of violation within 1 year of its occurrence and not after that.
    5. After enquiry, It may recommend the concerned government or authority
      1. To make payment of compensation or damages to the victim.
      2. The initiation of proceedings or any other action against the guilty public servant.
      3. For the grant of immediate interim relief to the victim.
    6. It may approach the SC or HC concerned for the necessary directions, orders and writs.
    7. It can summon witnesses, question any govt official, demand any official paper, visit any prison for inspection or send it's own team for on the spot inquiry.
  • Criticisms:
    1. It has no power to punish the violators of Human Rights nor can it provide any relief to the victim.
    2. The functions are mainly recommendatory in nature. Not binding. But it should be informed about the action taken on its recommendations within 1 month.
    3. The Commission has a limited role, powers and jurisdiction wrt violation of human rights by the member of Armed forces. In this sphere NHRC may seek a report from Govt and make recommendations. Center has to inform on actions taken within 3 months.
    4. Yet the govt considers cases forwarded by it. It is therefore improper to say that the Commission is powerless. It enjoys great material authority and no govt can ignore its recommendations.
    5. NHRC submits its annual report to Central govt and State govt concerned. SHRC submits to State govt.
  • Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 also provides for the establishment of Human Rights Courts:
    1. Acc to the act, HRC can be est in every district for speedy trial of violation of Human Rights.
    2. These Courts can be set up by the State govt only w the concurrence of concerned CJHC.
    3. For every HRC, State govt specifies a public prosecutor or appoints an advocate (practice > 7 years) as a special public prosecutor.
    4. Protection of Human Rights (Amendment) Act, 2006
      1. NHRC can undertake visits to jails even without intimation to State Govt.
      2. Chairman and members of NHRC resign to Prez, and SHRC resigns to Guv.
      3. NHRC can transfer complaints received by it to SHRCs.

Source: TH


Critically Important Antimicrobials (CIA)

The findings of a new survey by the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) underscored the need for properly monitoring critically important antimicrobials to mitigate AMR. CIAs – They represent a class of antimicrobials. Categorised by – World Health Organisation (WHO). 3 groups – Based on thei

Pong dam

Recently the draft policy was prepared to declare Pong Dam Wildlife Sanctuary and the surrounding area an eco-sensitive zone. It is the highest earth-fill dam in India and is one of India’s largest man-made reservoir. Built in – 1975, named after Maharana Pratap and so called as Maharana Pratap Sagar.

TM Module-2 in ICD-11

Recently ICD-11 was launched with the inclusion of Traditional Medicine Module 2. ICD-11 – International Classification of Diseases 11th Revision, the global standard for diagnostic health information. Launched by – World Health Organisation (WHO). Prepared by – WHO in collaboration with Mi

World Employment and Social Outlook Report 2023

Released by- International Labour Organisation Publication- Annually Theme- The value of essential work. About- It details the impact of economic slowdown on the global labour market. 2023 report- It calls for a revaluation of the work of key workers to reflect their social contribution and greater investment in

First Advanced Estimate (FEA) of GDP & GDP CALCULATION

Recently, the 1st Advance Estimates (FAEs) released by the government showed that India’s GDP will grow by 7.3% in the current financial year (2023-24), slightly faster than the 7.2% growth in 2022-23. What is GDP? Gross Domestic Product – GDP is defined as total market value of all final goods and services in

DNA

01 Feb,2024

Toppers

Search By Date

Post Feed

Newsletter Subscription
SMS Alerts

Important Links