×

UPSC Courses

DNA banner

DAILY NEWS ANALYSIS

  • 20 April, 2021

  • 5 Min Read

Ken-Betwa project- environmental hazards

Ken-Betwa project- environmental hazards

Introduction

  • Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and the Centre signed a tripartite agreement to transfer “surplus” water from the Ken basin in M.P. to the “deficit” Betwa basin in U.P.

About Ken-Betwa project

  • First mooted in the 1980s, the Ken-Betwa project was taken up seriously only during former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s regime.
  • The Ken-Betwa project is part of the national river linking project which proposes to connect 14 Himalayan and 16 peninsular rivers with 30 canals and 3,000 reservoirs in order to irrigate 87 million hectares of land.
  • It has the status of a national project, as the Centre will contribute 90% of the cost.
  • It is India’s first river linking project and will take eight years to complete.

Importance of the project

  • The project, the government says, will enhance the irrigation potential of the water-starved Bundelkhand region in U.P. and M.P., facilitate groundwater recharge and reduce the occurrence of floods.
  • According to the Memorandum of Agreement signed, the to-be-built Daudhan dam is expected to irrigate nearly 6,00,000 hectares in four districts in M.P. and 2,51,000 hectares in four districts in U.P. and provide drinking water supply to 41 lakh people in M.P. and 21 lakh in U.P.

Environmental concerns

  • However, the excitement of planners and politicians about this project, which costs ?37,611 crore (2018 figure), is reportedly missing on the ground.
  • In public hearings held in the past, they were divided on political lines and also worried about the loss of the ecosystem and displacement.
  • Of the 12,500 hectares of land to get submerged by the project, more than 9,000 ha are categorised as forest land.
  • The submergence area includes a critically important section of the Panna Tiger Reserve.
    • The Reserve is considered as a shining example of conservation after it successfully improved the tiger and vulture populations.
  • Around 40% of the area of the tiger reserve will be irretrievably damaged if the project is implemented.
  • Also, the project may destroy about 7.2 lakh trees.
  • South Asia Network on Dams, River and People convener Himanshu Thakkar fears that this will affect rainfall in the already parched region.

Cost and benefit

  • The claims of Ken having surplus water may be unrealistic as the river is not perennial — in the past sometimes, it has slowed to a trickle.
  • Another difficulty will be that the Ken flows 60-70 feet lower than the Betwa and at least 30% of the 103 MW power generated will be used for pumping the water up.
  • The Union Ministry and the National Water Development Agency, which is entrusted with the project, have some issues to sort out.
  • These include getting clearance from the Central Empowered Committee of the Supreme Court, which had raised concerns about the project.
  • The cost-benefits calculations of the project also don’t take into consideration the environmental and social impacts.
  • Thus, the benefits do not seem certain and are far outweighed by the costs on the environment.

Way forward

  • It is surprising that alternatives such as water-conservation and water-harvesting methods without building a dam haven’t been seriously considered in the region.
  • Large-scale solutions such as this are not always viable and the best.

Conclusion

  • Given the serious doubts about the benefits of the project and the monumental toll that it would have on the ecosystem, including on carefully preserved wildlife, the Ken-Betwa project seems like a huge, costly mistake.

Source: TH


E-pharmacies

E-pharmacies The Ministry of Health sent "show cause" letters to at least 20 businesses in February 2023 for online drug sales, including Tata-1mg, Flipkart, Apollo, PharmEasy, Amazon, and Reliance Netmeds. What is e-pharmacy? E-pharmacy refers to the purchasing and selling of drugs and other pharmaceutical products through a

Punchhi Commission Report

Punchhi Commission Report The Punchhi Commission's report on relations between the federal government and its constituent states will now be reviewed for state responses, according to the Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA). Historical Background: A Commission on Centre-State Relations was established by the Indian government,

Indo-German Relations

Indo-German Relations Olaf Scholz, the Chancellor of Germany, recently paid a bilateral visit to India. It is Scholz's first trip to India after taking office as German Chancellor in December 2021, ending Angela Merkel's illustrious 16-year reign. About the news: The visit of the German chancellor is significant because i

India Denmark Cooperation

India Denmark Cooperation During the "India-Denmark: Partners for Green and Sustainable Development Conference" in New Delhi, the Union Minister for Environment, Forests, and Climate Change said that India and Denmark can work together to show that reaching ambitious climate and sustainable energy targets is possible. Since the Gr

Mob lynching and Cow Vigilantism

Mob lynching and Cow Vigilantism The recent lynching and burning of two men in Haryana on the basis of allegations of unlawful cow slaughter, smuggling, or transportation bring attention to the problem of mob lynching. About cow vigilantism: Mob attacks carried out in the guise of "cow protection" primarily target Mus

Toppers

Search By Date

Post Feed

Newsletter Subscription
SMS Alerts