DAILY NEWS ANALYSIS

GS-III : Economic Issues Education

08 June, 2021
8 Min Read

Performance Grading Index (PGI)- Analysis

Introduction

High-performing States with good schools can nudge others if they have the political will

Performance Grading Index (PGI)

The Union Education Ministry has been attempting to get States into a competitive mode in upgrading their school education system by recognising progress with a Performance Grading Index (PGI) that assigns them a score.
- It can be argued that countries and State governments use school education as a transformative tool most effectively where the political imperative is strong.
The Centre’s effort with the PGI scoring system has been to try and nudge all States using a hall of fame approach.
The score is derived using databases on 70 parameters such as: access, equity, governance processes, infrastructure and facilities, and learning outcomes that are mostly self-reported by the States but vetted by the Centre, with National Achievement Survey data also being incorporated.

About PGI:

The PGI for States and Union Territories was first published in 2019 with reference year 2017-18.

Implementing Agency:

It is initiated by the Department of School Education and Literacy (DoSEL).

Source:

The information on the indicators are drawn from data available with:
- the DoSEL from the Unified District Information System for Education (UDISE),
- National Achievement Survey (NAS) of NCERT,
- Mid Day Meal website,
- Public Financial Management System (PFMS) and
- the information uploaded by the States and UTs on the Shagun portal of DoSEL.

Method:

The PGI is structured in two categories- Outcomes and Governance & Management and comprises 70 indicators in aggregate with a total weightage of 1000.
Domains:
- Access,
- Infrastructure & Facilities,
- Equity,
- Governance process.

PGI findings:

In the latest set of scores and grades for the pre-COVID-19 year, 2019-20, the Andaman and Nicobar islands, Chandigarh, Kerala, Punjab and Tamil Nadu have performed the best, although they still fall short of the 951-1,000 points slab, the highest possible.
33 States and Union Territories that their PGI scores have improved over the previous year.
Andaman and Nicobar, Punjab and Arunachal Pradesh, by a noteworthy 20%. (Highest improvement)
Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh actually regressed, although the PGI scheme is now three years old.
The PGI scores show that the southern and western States are on firm ground to achieve this, while those in central India and parts of the east and Northeast are less resourced.

Increase in transparency

The Centre, with its transparent scores and data for each parameter and sub-topic made available in the public domain
It seeks to create a resource-sharing system that low-performing States can tap into.

Need for coordination

It can work only if governments and Opposition parties see value in strong and open school education
To strengthen access, equity and infrastructure by budgeting fees and funds for universalisation.

Japan model:

It is such commitment that led Southeast Asia to carry out a renaissance in school education in the later decades of the last century, on the lines of Meiji-era Japan.

Way forward

Further progress on all parameters will depend on bridging the gaps, particularly on digital tools, infrastructure and subsidies for access.
What is evident from the Education Ministry analysis is that governance processes are the weakest link in some States.
A new deal for schools can transform them as the Right to Education law envisages.

Source: TH

Join Our Telegram

Punchhi Commission Report

E-pharmacies

08 Mar, 23
SHARE

E-pharmacies The Ministry of Health sent "show cause" letters to at least 20 businesses in February 2023 for online drug sales, including Tata-1mg, Flipkart, Apollo, PharmEasy, Amazon, and Reliance Netmeds. What is e-pharmacy? E-pharmacy refers to the purchasing and selling of drugs and other pharmaceutical products through a

Punchhi Commission Report

08 Mar, 23
SHARE

Punchhi Commission Report The Punchhi Commission's report on relations between the federal government and its constituent states will now be reviewed for state responses, according to the Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA). Historical Background: A Commission on Centre-State Relations was established by the Indian government,

Indo-German Relations

08 Mar, 23
SHARE

Indo-German Relations Olaf Scholz, the Chancellor of Germany, recently paid a bilateral visit to India. It is Scholz's first trip to India after taking office as German Chancellor in December 2021, ending Angela Merkel's illustrious 16-year reign. About the news: The visit of the German chancellor is significant because i

India Denmark Cooperation

07 Mar, 23
SHARE

India Denmark Cooperation During the "India-Denmark: Partners for Green and Sustainable Development Conference" in New Delhi, the Union Minister for Environment, Forests, and Climate Change said that India and Denmark can work together to show that reaching ambitious climate and sustainable energy targets is possible. Since the Gr

Mob lynching and Cow Vigilantism

07 Mar, 23
SHARE

Mob lynching and Cow Vigilantism The recent lynching and burning of two men in Haryana on the basis of allegations of unlawful cow slaughter, smuggling, or transportation bring attention to the problem of mob lynching. About cow vigilantism: Mob attacks carried out in the guise of "cow protection" primarily target Mus